In court papers, Lambda Legal seeks recovery for damages suffered by Brett Timmerman after he was attacked because he is gay.

Timmerman, who was a student at the University of Wisconsin-Platteville at the time of the alleged assault, was about to walk into a local sandwich shop when his would-be attackers called him a ‘faggot,’ according to a Lambda Legal release. Then Oden Waite and Enove Urias allegedly slapped and spit in Timmerman’s face and struck him in the head before pushing him to the ground. Eventually, Waite was arrested, and both Waite and Urias later accused Timmerman of starting the fight that led to a citation for disorderly conduct against Timmerman. The citation was later dismissed.

Lambda Legal’s argument invokes the Wisconsin hate crime law, which allows civil suits after someone engages in conduct that would trigger a hate crime penalty even if the person was not charged with or convicted of a crime.