Fred G. Thompson was born in 1888 in Youngstown, Ohio, but raised on a farm near Columbus. Adopted as a youngster, his home life was terrible, and he ran away to Columbus to work as a bellboy in a hotel there, and after saving as much money as he could, he left for Chicago a few months later. Asked what he’d done to survive on Chicago’s streets, he replied, “‘I’d hate to tell you.” The truth of the matter was that he became a prostitute: “‘A week … in a boy’s suit alternated with months of living in girl’s skirts.” He called himself “Frances.” Chicago police often arrested her on morals charges.

On May 23, 1912, she legally married Frank Carrick, a junkie, in Crown Point, Ind. Frank claimed not to have known she was a biological male until many months later, although he admitted, too, that he didn’t care that she was a he. By 1915, Frances had become so successful at her profession that she managed her own “disorderly house,” a euphemism for a bordello, which was two adjacent apartments in a building at Erie and LaSalle in Towertown, a neighborhood in what is now known as the Gold Coast that served as Chicago’s north side epicenter of queer life.

Frances was also a singer and had performed “at the Erie [Café], the Athenia [Inn], and others on North Clark,” including McGovern’s Saloon, as well as at two amusement parks, “Riverview and … Forest Park.” Rumor had it that she had once performed as “May Belmont, comedienne and dancer” briefly in Syracuse, NY. The police knew her as “‘Nanny White,'” when she was the madam of “a place at 43 N. Dearborn.”

In 1920, Frances was introduced to Marie Clark by another madam, Helen Williams, and Marie took an immediate liking to Frances, “whom she thought “a wonderful girl.'” Frances and Marie looked so much alike they could’ve passed for sisters. Noting Marie’s attraction to Frances, Helen told Marie that Frances was really Fred, but Marie fell in love with him anyway. They began to date. “‘We went together for a couple of months. He wore girl’s clothes, swell ones, too, most of the time,'” Marie later recalled. The Rev. G.C. Prince legally married the two Jan. 27, 1921 at Moody Bible Institute. Frances showed up as Fred, wearing a suit. Frances/Fred was not only queer and a prostitute but now also a bigamist.

The two left Frank and moved to Elmhurst, where they bought land and began to farm and where Frances lived as Fred. After five months tilling the soil, they changed their minds about living off the land. Besides, Frances had had it with being Fred. They moved back to Towertown. Frank heard Frances was back and showed up on their doorstep. She let him to move in with them, and Frances returned to prostitution.

Jealous of Frances’ many male admirers—”‘Fred dressed like a woman most of the time,'” Marie recalled, “‘and gee, I hated to see him step out with other gents”—Marie began taking it out on Frank, fighting with him every chance she got. Not to be outdone by a woman, Frank fought back. After months of it, Marie turned to heroine for solace as Frank had years earlier, and then after getting hooked, she decided to quit cold turkey. She went home to her family in Detroit.

While trying to kick the habit at a local hospital, Marie developed blood poisoning and nearly died. But her family contacted Frances and begged her to come to Detroit and nurse their child back to health. She did.

Then at around 11 p.m. on Tuesday, June 5, 1923, Richard and Anna Tesmer were robbed at gunpoint by a male and female couple. The Tesmers were parking their Durant in the alley behind their home at 5835 Winthrop when the couple mugged them and, in the process, the woman shot Mr. Tesmer, a “wealthy insurance man.” He died from his wounds shortly thereafter.

Mrs. Tesmer claimed to have seen the woman’s face clearly in the nanosecond of light given off by the pistol blast. She described the gun-wielding, twentysomething-year-old woman as having blue eyes and light hair, of wearing a brown dress and a floppy hat. She and her side-kick left the scene of the crime with nearly $25 in their pockets. “‘I’ll never forget that smile,'” Mrs. Tesmer “repeated over and over … as the police brought suspects before her.” According to Mrs. Tesmer, the murderer had “an evil, leering, satanic grin.”

Mrs. Tesmer never noticed the male accomplice’s face.

For several weeks, police rounded up women, most of whom had records or were somehow tied to the underworld, hopeful that Mrs. Tesmer would identify one as the murderer. She did. She pointed her finger at all of the suspects, claiming each was the culprit. The first were Gertrude Getson, a “paroled flapper bandit,” Anna Senback, Marge Bennett, and the wife of gangster Earl Dear. All were released when their alibis panned out.

Then police took Bertha Schillo, manicurist Peggy Le Beaux, an actress who was reputed to have been a drug addict, Corinne Gillispie Lafferty, wife of a man serving time in Joliet, and eighteen-year-old Margaret Ryan into custody. They, too, had air-tight alibis and were released. Finally, a man “whose name police would not disclose” and who had “been masquerading as a woman the night Tesmer was killed was questioned the night of June 14. He was released, too.

Reacting to a “hot tip,” police raided Frances’s apartment the morning of June 19. They arrived in full force, knocked on her door, and when she answered it, arrested her. She responded by “kicking, screaming oaths, and shouting boasts” until they stripped her of the kimono she was wearing and “bundled [her] into a blue frock and green hat” for the ride to Mrs. Tesmer’s home.

The police posed Frances with a pistol in front of the widow. It wobbled in her “grip.” “I ain’t ever had a gun in my hand,” Frances explained, but true to form, Mrs. Tesmer pointed her finger at the police’s latest suspect and, in a near swoon, shouted, “‘My God! That is the girl who murdered my husband. I can never forget those eyes and that smile. There is no doubt of it. I’ll never forget the look on her face. Lock her up. She can’t lie out of this.'” Frances was the last in a long line of “women” the widow identified as the murderer.

The police hauled Frances to the Hyde Park station for processing. They also took the other three persons who’d been in the apartment to keep her company: her husband, Frank Carrick; her wife, Marie; and a “‘pal,'” Anthony Kushar, whose real relationship to the other three was unclear. It was quite the dragnet.

At the station, the police immediately found themselves in a quandary. Frances’ five-o’clock shadow was not just showing, but was prominent, and they couldn’t decide whether to lock her up with the men or the women. They called in two doctors, Clara Seippel of the Morals Court and David J. Jones, City Physician, to examine their prisoner. Both agreed: Frances was a man.

At first, Frances claimed to have been sympathetic to Mrs. Tesmer’s loss. “When I saw her,” she said, “I felt sorry for her. Honest, I wanted to put my arms around her,” but her sympathy quickly waned. “‘That woman’s crazy,'” she later said. “‘I can beat the game….'” Then she added, “‘She already identified four or five girls. And she said she was waiting for blue eyes. Mine are grey.'” Besides, Frances had an alibi. She was at home the night Richard Tesmer was murdered, ill from drinking tainted moonshine.

From the beginning, Frances was confident that the police wouldn’t be able to pin the murder on her, but she stated from her jail cell her first night there, “‘faint heart n’er won fair lady, and I’m gonna fight.'” Then Frances “smoothed ‘her’ henna bob, deepened the mascarole under ‘her’ gimlet eyes of blue-grey, and traced a crimson cupid’s bow about ‘her’ wide-spread mouth.” As the officer turned the key in the cell lock, Frances “rubbed stubby fingers over a chin smeared with rouge and whiskers” and grumbled, “Hell, I wish they’d give me a safety razor an a shot of gin.”

As the police continued their investigation over the next few weeks, they questioned Frances’ husband, Frank, and her neighbors. Frank Carrick was a “tiny, anemic, wild eyed man,” “timid and jumpy,” and “Questioned frequently … regarding his connection with the murder …, the stupefied auto mechanic squirmed and twisted in his chair, but said nothing. Occasionally he would cough dryly. Sometimes he trembled and started at imaginary sounds.” Frank called himself an automobile mechanic, but he couldn’t remember the names of any of his employers for the past three years.

All of Frances’ neighbors swore that she was a biological woman, although they also had occasionally noticed a hint of a beard on her cheeks. When questioned by the police, one of Frances’ neighbors, Mrs. Della Thiele, who had no doubt that Frances was female, said, “It’ll take me a long time to listen to that racket about her being a man.” She was just as convinced by Frances’ innocence in the Termer murder and couldn’t imagine Frances being involved with any criminal activity. “We’d ‘a’ known it if she was up to that kinda stuff,” Mrs. Thiele said.

In the meantime, Frances had become a hot item in the news and was dubbed “the creature with the duplex psychology”—a phrase suggesting another one that was common in the medical literature of the time, “psychic hermaphrodites,” a label for effeminate, cross-dressing queer men. Initially, she was allowed to wear women’s clothing in her cell and in court, but when she was transferred from the police lockup to the country jail to await her trial, the warden demanded that she dress in male clothing.

While behind bars, Frances was quite vocal, and reporters ate it up. “Half in whimsy, half in seriousness, the man in woman’s clothes … discussed the possibility of writing a book,” a reporter noted. “‘I’d tell a few things,'” Frances admitted. “‘A lot of prominent guys right in this city will die when they hear about me being a man.'” Then when “Asked if many of ‘her’ friends were prominent men,” she replied, ‘Say, do you think I’m such a poor fish that I’d stop for the small guys if I could make the big ones?'”

Frustrated behind bars, Frances even volunteered to help the authorities, “Freddy swished ‘her’ trailing draperies [skirts] and tossed back over ‘her’ shoulder a mellow, defiant baritone assertion: ‘Believe me, I don’t know a damned thing about this mess. You help me and I’ll help you. We’ll go through the dope joints and we’ll get the girl who killed Tesmer.” The police didn’t take her up on her offer.

To keep boredom at bay while lawyers selected the jury, Frances “winked coquettishly at the men” but “ignored the women.” She loved to strike a pose for photographers, too.

Throughout the trial, which began Oct. 1, no one was quit sure which pronoun to use when referring to Freddie-Frances, as the gumshoes called the “man-girl,” another term reporters adopted for her. Making matters even more peculiar, Frances had quickly become a cause célèbre. Chief among her admirers were heterosexual women and men who were of the “‘cake eating type,'” as a reporter from the Chicago Daily News called the queer men in the audience. Frances had become a Towertown sensation.

Frances’ fate depended on whether or not the all-male jury believed her or Mrs. Tesmer. Mrs. Tesmer had testified that the killer was a twenty-year-old, blue-eyed blonde who had been dressed in a brown dress and floppy hat, but Frances hennaed her hair, had gray eyes, and was thirty-five. As one reporter reminded his readers, “‘Mrs. Carrick’ didn’t have light hair, but a streaked henna bob. No one has been able to discover that ‘she’ ever had a brown dress. In ‘her’ collection of fifteen hats there is no poke bonnet. ‘Her’ eyes are more gray than blue. And the ‘girl with the smile’ is a man, one who masqueraded for eighteen years in woman’s silks.” When the police searched her apartment, they didn’t find a brown dress or a floppy hat. Worst of all, the widow had “‘already identified four or five girls'” as the murderer before calling Frances the killer.

Frances’ lawyer, Frank McDonnell, called Frances’ husband to the stand. After being sworn in, McDonnell asked Carrick if he and Frances had been married, and when he said they had, Judge John Caverly interrupted the trial, told Carrick not to speak another word, and dismissed him. Carrick had been exempted from testifying because “‘the fact that Thompson was a man did not affect his status as a wife,'” and the judge “held that the fact that Thompson is a man did not affect his status as a wife, insofar as interpretation of the law is concerned.” Amazingly, not only did the court legally acknowledge a same-sex marriage but gave the same-sex couple the same rights as opposite-sex married couples had. One reporter called the judge’s decision “precedent-making.”

The next day, McDonnell called Frances to the stand. Through a gale of alligator tears, she told the story of her life, explaining how, as a child on the farm, she was ashamed of her obvious difference from the other boys. She described her life in Chicago, including her two marriages—one to a man, one to a woman. Her sobs became so infectious that her fans in the courtroom sobbed, too.

Then the jury was led away to deliberate Frances’ fate, and after only two hours, it returned with a not-guilty verdict and pandemonium broke out. Women and gay men in the audience rushed Frances to congratulate her, as she leaped up on the rail of the jury box and shook hands with the jurors.” A witness reported, “bailiffs rushed here and there through the densely packed crowd shouting for order, and engaged in a few skirmishes with spectators.”

On the courthouse steps a few minutes later, Frances spoke to reporters, concluding that “‘Everybody’s been swell to me—but, my goodness!—I’ll be glad to get some hair pins!'”

It was a message to all gay men who were there on the courthouse steps with her or who would read her good-bye in the newspapers the next day. At the time, to “drop hair pins” was a phrase common in the gay subculture that meant to reveal one’s sexual orientation to others, to “come out.” It was similar to “letting one’s hair down.” During her arrest and subsequent trial, Frances had been forced to drop her hairpins. All of Chicago now knew she was a he.

Interviewed by the press, Frances claimed that she “wanted to live a quiet life” and “had no desire for a public life of any kind,” but Frances had no intention of abandoning the spotlight now that she was basking in it. Within days, Frances headlined at the Rialto, a burlesque theater at 336 State Street, for $500 a week, drawing huge crowds.

Unfortunately for Frances, although the courts had upheld her rights as a wife, maintained the right of the two men to marry one another, and acknowledged her innocence in the murder of Richard Tesmer, the Chief of Police and the Mayor of Chicago joined forces to stop her.

Frances had been hired at “a huge salary” to perform what the press described as an “immoral and offensive” act. When asked by reporters, Mayor Dever said, “It is to be regretted that any audiences could be found to view such a person or that any management would cater to such perverted minds.” Police Chief Collins made a promise to the “‘good citizens'” of Chicago: “I shall halt this indecent spectacle, not only because it is an affront to all good citizens and an outrage to public morals … but also because it is highly improper that Thompson should be allowed to capitalize his perverted mentality. The police will keep him off the Chicago stage.”

Chief Colllins was good to his word. The Rialto’s management broke Frances’ contract, she left her singing career, and she was never heard of again.

—Sources of Citations—

“disorderly house”: “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'” Chicago Daily Tribune 21 June 1923: 1.

“May Belmont”: “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“at the Erie”: “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“‘We went together:'” “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.” Chicago Daily Tribune 22 June 1923: 12.

“‘Nanny White:'” “Unmask ‘Girl Slayer’ as Man.” Chicago Herald-Examiner 26 June 1923: 1

“whom she thought:” “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.” 12.

“‘Fred dressed like:'” “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.” 12.

“wealthy insurance man”: “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.” 1.

“‘I’ll never forget:” “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“an evil, leering:” “Unmask ‘Girl Slayer’ as Man.”

“paroled flapper bandit”: Chicago Daily Tribune 8 June 1923: 40.

“whose name police”: “‘Blue Eyes’ Doff Rouge for Tests as Girl Slayer.” Chicago Daily Tribune 16 June 1923: 7.

“hot tip:” “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“kicking, screaming oaths:” “Hold Man as ‘Girl Slayer.'” Chicago Daily Tribune, 20 June 1923: 1.

“‘My God! That:'” “Unmask ‘Girl Slayer’ as Man.” Chicago Herald-Examiner 26 June 1923: 1, 3.

“‘pal:'” “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“When I saw:” “Hold Man as ‘Girl Slayer.'” 1.

“faint heart n’er:” “Hold Man as ‘Girl Slayer.'” 12.

“smoothed ‘her’ henna:” “Hold Man as ‘Girl Slayer.'” 1.

“tiny, anemic, wild:” “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.”

“It’ll take me:” “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“the creature with:” “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.” 12.

“psychic hermaphrodites:” Brill, A.A. “The Conception of Homosexuality.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 2 August 1913: 336.

“Half in whimsy:” “Husband of Sex Hoaxer, Prey of Dope, Goes Mad.”

“Freddy swished ‘her:'” “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“winked coquettishly:” “‘Man-Girl’ Is Bored as Death Trial Opens.” Chicago Herald-Examiner 2 Oct. 1923: 6.

“man-girl:” “‘Man-Girl’ Faces Tesmer Murder Hearing Today.” Chicago Daily Tribune 23 June 1923: 3.

“‘cake eating type:'” Lesy, Michael. Murder City: The Bloody History of Chicago in the Twenties. New York: Norton, 2007. 164.

“‘Mrs. Carrick’ didn’t:'” “Trail Pal of ‘Bandit Girl.'”

“‘already identified four:'” Lesy 158.

“the fact that:” Lesy 166.

“held that the fact:” “Thompson Is Recognized as Wife by Court.” Chicago Herald-Examiner 3 Oct. 1923: 1.

“While Thompson leaped:” “‘Man-Girl’ Is Acquitted as Tesmer Testifies.” Chicago Herald-Examiner 4 Oct. 1923: 1, [?].

“‘Everybody’s been swell:'” Lesy 167.

“wanted to live:” “‘Man-Girl’ Is Acquitted as Tesmer Testifies.” 1.

“a huge salary:” “Police Prohibit Man-Girl Going on Stage Here.” Chicago Daily Tribune 7 Oct. 1923. 3.